Title
Author
Institution
Date
Two contrasting interpretations of the aims of citizenship education
Anna Wulmouth
Institute of Education, London University
13/10/2009
Two contrasting interpretations of the aims of citizenship education (CE), introduced as a compulsory component of the National Curriculum at key stages 3 and 4 in September 2002 , are possible. In this essay, I will argue that while one is highly complementary, the other is potentially in deep conflict with recent conceptions of the ‘employability' agenda that is also being promoted in schools.
What is the nature of citizenship education?: A critical investigation of the development of student voice as an aim of citizenship education
Judith Aelbery
N/A
19/02/2009
This essay will explore student voice as a salient and promoted aspect of citizenship education. It will take into account different considerations highlighted by various relevant research papers in order to show that student voice has worthwhile merit. It will explore the relevance of student voice within the curriculum and within society including different definitions, purposes and intentions of student voice. It will identify different considerations and measures that need to be implemented in schools in order to achieve a successful student voice. It will investigate Davies and Yamashita's (2007) suggested ‘6 building blocks' in turn and argue a case for a 7th to be added. It will go on to investigate possible negative consequences of superficially implementing student voice and further explore any detrimental effects it could have on young people's futures if schools are not fully committed to empowering students. In conclusion it will review the importance of student voice outlined by the aims of citizenship education and investigate the opportunities for success.
Value and contribution of citizenship education.
George Boss and Tracy Caller
University of Bristol
19/02/2008
Two assignments from students on the PGCE at Bristol University who were asked to write a persuasive article for an educational journal that would convince teachers of the value and contribution of citizenship education.
Gifted and Talented Pupils in Citizenship Education: The Opportunity to Shine
Laura Johnson, (Tutor: Jeremy Hayward)
Institute of Education
13/09/2006
Citizenship is a new subject in the National Curriculum which aims to provide pupils with the knowledge and skills to participate fully in society. Providing for pupils of all abilities, while facing pressures on time and resources, is a daily challenge for citizenship teachers. Pupils identified by schools as ‘gifted and talented’ may benefit from specific help which allows them to fully engage with the Citizenship curriculum. This essay asks who ‘gifted and talented’ pupils might be within the context of Citizenship; explores whether in fact time-pressured teachers should differentiate for these pupils, and finally focuses on practical and effective provision for ‘gifted and talented’ pupils in Citizenship lessons.
Islamophobia in the British Educational Sector
Farah Shaik (Tutor: Ian Davies)
University of York
18/07/2006
This paper seeks to critically explore and lay out numerous factors, which could be contributing to Islamophobic attitudes entailing non-differentiated views of Muslims in relation to what today is referred to as “terrorism”, “radicalism” and “the war against terror”. With respect to community, the main objective of this enquiry is to point out the high level of significance this type of Islamophobia can have for both Muslim and Non-Muslim members of society, and what lack of understanding thereof could be establishing within the framework of education. By being the target of xenophobic attitudes, the Muslim youth may be well be placed unwillingly before a loyalty-conflict between Muslim identity and British identity, which is currently the cause of much debate in Britain and questions of community belongingness. There is an urgent need for educators and policy makers to be aware of the complexity of the whole situation whilst adopting a constructive no-blame-approach and of recognizing potential victims of such alienation and discrimination, which is often undetected and has a major impact on lastly everyone in society.
Community Service Learning: An Approach to Facilitate Citizenship Education in Higher Education
Sicong Chen
N/A
13/07/2006
Based on the discussion about the current situation of citizenship education in higher education in the UK, including the considerable similarity between the aim of citizenship education and that of higher education, and the relatively weak status of citizenship education in higher education, this paper draws attention on community service learning, one of whose features is community involvement. It tries to argue that community service learning, which emphasizes on both community service and outcomes, could be an effective way for university students to participate practically in community and gain knowledge, skills and attitudes for being active citizens, and, could be a feasible approach for universities to replay its civic role in communities. In a word, learning through Community service as an approach is worthy of taking into account if citizenship education is to be facilitated further in higher education.
Case Study: Effective Assessment In Citizenship Education
Michael McCann (Tutor:)
Exeter University
21/06/2006
“Assessment is currently a weak aspect of Citizenship.” (Ofsted,2003). This judgement by Her Majesty’s Inspectors suggests that those who wish to deliver effective Citizenship Education need to have a better understanding of the role that assessment has in Citizenship. More specifically, providers of Citizenship education should be aware of the rationale behind assessment, the benefits and pitfalls of assessment, the various methods of conducting assessment and ultimately, they should be able to identify and address the current problems within Citizenship assessment. By conducting a literature review on assessment and then examining my own assessment techniques, through a case study from my first placement, I hope to achieve a greater understanding of assessment principles and also develop and improve my methods of assessment for future practice.
What lessons does the pedagogical approach of Paulo Freire have for the development of Citizenship as a national curriculum subject?
Nick Lawson (Tutor: Jeremy Hayward)
Institute of Education
11/07/2005
This essay critically examines the pedagogical writings of Paulo Freire and considers what lessons it holds for the development of Citizenship teaching in England today. It argues that while the details of Paulo Freire’s educational programme are for another time and place, his approach to education, in teaching about the world through literacy programmes and rejecting the “banking” approach to education holds many lessons for educators today. This essay then relates Freire’s pedagogy to the development of political literacy as a strand of the Citizenship programme of study. It then considers the importance of developing a sense of agency amongst students in developing political literacy as opposed to political knowledge. It also contrasts Paulo Freire’s pedagogy with that proposed by The Crick Report (1998) and examines contemporary critiques of Crick’s approach to the development of political literacy and the Citizenship curriculum. It then examines omissions in Paulo Freire’s approach with particular reference to multiculturalism and consider how Freire’s pedagogy can be implemented in schools today.
School Councils
Ben Howard (Tutor Jeremy Hayward)
Institute of Education
18/04/2005
This paper explores the concept of participation in Citizenship education. Specifically, it demonstrates the crucial role of democratic school structures, such as school councils, in developing young people’s sense of agency, which is a necessary precursor to their participation in public life in adulthood. While acknowledging the limitations of school democracy, the essay argues that it represents a paragon necessary to ensure every child has the opportunity to participate at school in an effective manner. To this end legislation for statutory school councils is called for.
Citizenship education through community Action
James Hadley (Tutor Cathie Holden)
Exeter
07/02/2005
At first, this paper will provide an overview of the current debate about what constitutes ‘good’ community action. It will then outline my proposal and show how it fits in with the requirements of the OCR GCSE coursework, the National Curriculum and National Curriculum Key Skills. A justification for the project that I have selected will then be offered; identifying the benefits to both community and volunteers, along with contingency plans should they not suit the students’ interests and concerns. The lesson plans will focus on one example project and show exactly how the work will be conducted over three lessons, taking into account the needs of SEN pupils and Health and Safety requirements as well as practical considerations. Assessment criteria (that are linked to the OCR short-course, National Curriculum and National Curriculum Key Skills) for the project will then be outlined, followed, finally, by a critical reflection on the process of doing this assignment.
Education for democracy in an autocratic formal education system: increasing student participation in schools.
Kate Brown (Tutor Jeremy Hayward)
Institute of Education
07/07/2004
Citizenship education aims to produce individuals with the knowledge and skills to participate in democracy. Those involved with Citizenship delivery are therefore faced with the inherent tension of developing skills of participation in the context of a hierarchical and autocratic school system. This essay acknowledges this tension, and recognizes it as a challenge for schools and teachers. However, there are ever increasing opportunities for student participation throughout their school experience. A model is presented that provides a framework for thinking about these opportunities for students’ to develop their skills of democratic participation.
Critically evaluate the nature and purpose of Citizenship education in relation to the National Curriculum and with specific reference to a unit of lessons you have planned
Matthew Duggins (Tutor: Ralph Leighton)
Canterbury Christchurch University
15/01/2004
Introduction In this essay I hope to examine some of the literature surrounding the rationale and implementation of Citizenship education and argue that, although the teaching of the subject is problematical and beset with certain difficulties, these can be negated, or at least moderated, by placing the development of skills and understanding at the heart of any Citizenship programme. I will then outline a set of three lessons that I have prepared, dealing primarily with rights and responsibilities, and explain how I think they incorporate my thinking from the first section, particularly in terms of ideology, methodology, aims and focus. Lastly, I will reflect on how my understanding and development have been enhanced by this investigation and how my ideas and practice may benefit from the conclusions I have drawn.
Citizenship: Power or Indoctrination?
Abby French (Tutor: Ralph Leighton)
Canterbury Christ Church University
29/09/2003
Introduction The final report of the Advisory Group on Citizenship (1998) unanimously and strongly advised the Secretary of State, that Citizenship must be made a statutory part of the National Curriculum, in order to change the political culture of the country. They stated that 'unless we become a nation of engaged citizens, our democracy is not secure' (Ibid:8). Despite many positive aspects of an education for citizenship, there has been, and continues to be, heavy criticism of its nature and purpose. For example, Garratt (2000) identifies the possibility of indoctrination, specifically in relation to political values. Indeed, I was initially very concerned about this possibility, after hearing about its proposed introduction during my degree in 2002.
How is the work of the Metropolitan Police and Youth Justice Boards Safer Schools Partnership helping to promote effective citizenship in London Secondary Schools?
Lee Faith(Tutor: Jill Rutter)
London Metropolitan University
17/09/2003
An examination of controversial issues in the New Brunswick Education System.
Matt Heywood (Tutor: Ian Davies)
University of York
28/07/2003
An Investigation into The Concept of Human Rights.
Jessie Dickens (Tutor: Lee Jerome)
Anglia Polytechnic University
09/07/2003
Exploring toleration in the context of lessons about Northern Ireland.
Sam Challis (Tutor: Ian Davies)
University of York
08/07/2003
What role can citizenship education play in reducing homophobia in schools?
David Morgan (Tutor: Jill Rutter)
London Metropolitan University
02/07/2003
How can the introduction of Citizenship address the issue of underachievement and disengagement among ethnic minority students?
Samuel Marlow (Tutor: Jeremy Hayward)
Institute of Education
02/07/2003
Student Reflections on Teaching Citizenship
Elspeth Horn (Tutor: Jane Perryman)
Goldsmith College, University of London
25/06/2003
Teaching the Ethics of Economic Globalisation
Joanna Wilcox (Tutor: James Arthur)
Canterbury Christ Church University
09/06/2003
Abstract A theoretical examination of ethical principles underlying key perspectives on economic globalisation is used to justify an approach to teaching the subject as an ethical issue. In the light of this, theories of moral development and approaches to moral education are considered and related to statutory requirements on teaching political issues and the guidelines of the Crick Report (1998). A developmental approach to teaching strategies is suggested. Practical issues in teaching a unit of work on economic globalisation are discussed, and implications for professional development are outlined. Recommendations are made for further research in this area.
The Relationship between citizenship and personal and social and health education (pshe): theory and practice
Victoria Orviss (Tutor: Hugh Starkey)
University of Leicester
09/06/2003